“It’s an interesting thing,” she mused. “When you don’t have romantic designs on someone, you’re more willing to be telling all and vulnerable. And I let him see my quirks, he let me see his in a way that I don’t think you’d do if you just started out dating.”

And though they were aligned in the bedroom, one place in which the couple differed was on the place of jealousy in a relationship.

While T.J. said “hell no” on whether expressing the emotion can be healthy in a relationship, Amy explained her POV on the subject. 

“I wouldn’t like to act on that jealousy, or be petty or small,” she said. “But feeling that bit of jealousy makes me know that I want to be with him and only him, and I want him to be with me and only me. I don’t like the feeling, but knowing it’s there actually in a weird way makes me feel good.”

But overall, the couple—whose relationship was made public in Nov. 2022, resulting in the loss of their GMA3 hosting jobs—scored an 84 percent compatibility score, which Michael said was “really high.”

As he put it, “Were you both aligned on was the really important, core factors of a relationship. It was clear from the beginning you were aligned on family matters, on what you’re looking for in a relationship. That’s really what’s most important.”

Keep reading for a look their romance.