The wildly popular sitcom, Two and a Half Men aired in 2003 and lasted twelve years on television through revision and recasting. The show had eight great seasons with Charlie Sheen, Jon Cryer, and Angus T. Jones as the titular two-and-a-half men. But after a loud, angry, and very public dispute between producers and Sheen, he was fired from the show. The series prevailed for four more seasons despite Sheen’s untimely career death, the outlandish remarks he was making at the time led to his erasure from the short list of Hollywood regulars. But as the title of the show demands two men, Sheen’s character was ultimately replaced by Walden Schmidt (Ashton Kutcher).
MOVIEWEB VIDEO OF THE DAYSCROLL TO CONTINUE WITH CONTENT

Updated May 26th, 2023: If you’re a fan of Two and a Half Men, then you’ll be happy to know this article has been updated by Grayson Uckele with additional content.

The series initially followed a pair of brothers, Charlie Harper (Charlie Sheen) and Alan Harper (Jon Cryer), as they navigate adult troubles and relationships despite polarizing their personalities. Charlie Harper is an unentangled, free spirit who invites his brother, Alan, and nephew, Jake, to move into his Malibu home as Alan settles his divorce. Alan’s more high-strung and prefers order, so his introduction to Charlie’s somewhat lawless home leads to a number of antics. Charlie Sheen’s expulsion from the show caused showrunners to revisit the writer’s room, where Charlie Harper was killed off and replaced with billionaire Walden Schmidt.

Walden, played by Aston Kutcher, is introduced in the episode centered around Charlie’s funeral. The downtrodden billionaire is suffering after a divorce and buys Harper’s Malibu beach house as a method of escapism. Realizing the situation Alan is put in, Walden generously lets Alan and his son stay in his new home for “a month, tops.” Of course, this arrangement leads to the following four seasons. The departure of Charlie Harper and the introduction of Walden Schmidt caused viewership to plummet, which led many fans to wonder – was Ashton Kutcher the kiss of death for the once-celebrated sitcom?

Charlie at the Center of Two and a Half Men

CBS

It’s difficult to deny that the show favored Charlie’s character for its first eight seasons. The obvious fan-favorite was the pivot point for the extenuating cast. Everyone in the series’ wide ensemble cast was defined by their relationship with Charlie Harper — a brother, a nephew, a mother (Evelyn), a stalker (Rose, played by Melanie Lynskey from Yellowjackets and Heavenly Creatures), and his rude housekeeper (Berta).

Charlie’s relationships with them defined the show, as did Charlie’s terrible behavior, narcissism, misanthropy, bafflingly bad judgment, and addiction. He is both a sex addict and a drunken drug user. Charlie manages to have sex with just about every woman on the show, although it’s uncertain how without the looks or charm. Watching Charlie Sheen play Harper as the character everyone hates to root for was what made the show so great. Charlie is his own worst enemy, a slave to his desires for women, alcohol, and dangerous activity.

Related: The Big Bang Theory: Who Would Make the Best Roommate?

Despite his many faults, Charlie is well-established within the series’ world as a jingle writer. He attended Juilliard, though he was expelled for characteristic bad behavior. Harper moved to Los Angeles with the hopes of becoming a film composer but fell short as a jingle writer. The jingles business has since declined, but not before Charlie managed to write a couple of successful tunes. He lives his life of debauchery off of the residuals made from jingles he wrote in the past and spends his days under some sort of influence as he moves through life as an eternal child. That’s not all there is to his character, though, he’s made two-dimensional in his relatable phobias and uncharacteristic generosity towards his brother and nephew. He’s a flawed character but somewhat impossible to hate.

Two and a Half Men After Charlie Sheen

CBS

Meanwhile, Kutcher’s Walden does not have a place in this world. Walden is somewhat of a hero, while Charlie has always been an antihero on the show. Most of his comments, especially to Alan, are insulting and cruel. He starts arguments and constantly reminds Alan that he is a leech and reserves his most critical comments for his mother. He is extremely honest about the flaws of other people and his own flaws, and through his character, the show becomes a lesson in dysfunction. That is until Walden comes in and ruins the vibe.

When Charlie left the show, it imploded, while his next show, Anger Management, was a total failure, completely lacking in the humor and great characterizations that made Two and a Half Men so entertaining to watch. Even with the addition of his real-life father, Martin Sheen, the show still failed to attract viewers. One has to wonder if the great Martin Sheen thought it was a good role or whether he took it for the sake of his son, with the latter seeming more likely. But Charlie was just as lost without Two and a Half Men as it was lost without him, and Anger Management and Two and A Half Men’s Walden era were two of the worst shows of their time, lacking comedy, realistic relationships, and anything grounded – adrift like a boat floating out at sea with no direction in mind.

While audiences loved Charlie as a self-aware bad boy, Walden came across as nerdy and boring. Viewers weren’t tuning in to be preached at, they were tuning in to be entertained by Charlie Harper’s overtly critical debauchery. Harper’s pessimistic, misanthropic takes and self-destructive behavior brought an element of gritty realism to the show that Walden’s character lacked. How Walden came to own Charlie’s house and inherit Charlie’s brother and nephew was convoluted and unrealistic. Right from Walden’s first episode, the show lost a certain level of realism.

Walden Can’t Maintain Charlie’s Relationships

CBS

Audiences initially responded well to Charlie’s relationship with his mother, which was both hilarious and sad, as she is a complete narcissist (just like Charlie) and not a particularly good mother, an expert at using guilt to get what she wants. She is a real estate agent and, like a vulture, is always reading the obituaries looking for new houses to come onto the market. Charlie and Alan see her as the anti-Christ and want to protect Jake from her. Her dialogue with Charlie was always funny, though somewhat painful, and it was great to see the two of them arguing.

Related: TV Shows From The Early 2000s They Could Never Air Today

Walden’s relationship with her is different. Their estrangement has no room for the same humor and, again, causes a decline in the show’s grit. Walden is nothing but a surrogate for Charlie in his relationship with the mother as well as the other characters, such as Jake and Alan. Instead of a complete rewrite, it seems the writers got lazy and applied Walden to the existing cast that used to revolve so expertly around Harper. When the show demanded a complete scrap and revision, Walden’s character operated as a band-aid.

The Family Dynamic Changed in Two and a Half Men

CBS

Alan is always there, encouraging Charlie to do the right thing, and on the occasions when Charlie sacrifices something (usually a random sex encounter) for the benefit of Jake, it’s hard not to like Charlie. Jake brings out another side to him, the father figure side, which makes for great comedy and drama. That is why, despite being raunchy with characters who do nasty things, the show can also be sweet (and bittersweet) at times, and the show’s best moments are with Charlie and Jake. For example, Charlie frequently gives advice about women to Jake, and the advice usually backfires, which is a constant source of humor and a way for us to better identify with and like the characters. Charlie tries to do the right thing by giving dating advice, but of course, Alan is appalled by what Charlie tells Jake.

That entire family dynamic is gone with Walden, who sees Jake as a joke and lacks the tender feelings that Charlie had towards him. Walden’s premise also destroys the story of two very different brothers trying to live together despite their differences, the source of a lot of the show’s humor. For example, there is a great episode in which Charlie finally confesses to setting up Alan as a shoplifter when they were kids. This makes Alan fearful that a “bad Alan” exists until he hears the truth, prompting him to attack Charlie. Again, the dynamic of the two very different brothers is gone, replaced by the superficial and unfunny relationship between Walden and Alan.

Charlie’s death also ruined his mother, Evelyn’s role. She was at her best when arguing with Charlie and criticizing his lifestyle, and the moments between these two characters are golden, containing both humor and pathos. Evelyn and Walden are two random people, and their chemistry is non-existent. They are not bound to each other because they are not family and have no history. Again, the family dynamic is disrupted by Walden.

Two and a Half Men Was Charlie Sheen’s Show

CBS

The show is called Two and a Half Men, but it is really Charlie’s show. He is basically playing himself, a trainwreck of a personality addicted to vices like sex with anyone and everyone, whether they are married or not, drinking excessively, taking drugs, gambling, and engaging in self-destructive behavior. It’s great and funny to see the actor play himself, often moody and whining about Alan and his son.

After Charlie Sheen was fired, CBS could have just ended the series as his final episode actually marked a natural conclusion for the series. Yet Two and a Half Men was one of the biggest shows on television at the time, and they did not want to let it go. Bringing in Kutcher seemed like a smart move, as he was fondly remembered from the popular series That ’70s Show. Yet in an ironic twist of fate, similar to That ’70s Show trying to replace Topher Grace’s Eric with Josh Myers Randy. Audiences roundly rejected the character of Randy, and That ’70s Show ended shortly after. Kutcher found himself in a role that in the past doomed his own show. To Two and a Half Men’s credit, audiences still did stick around for the series for another four seasons, even to the point when Angus T. Jones left, and his role in the series was filled by Amber Tamblyn’s Jenny, who was the unknown daughter of Charlie Sheen’s character. Jenny’s presence was an attempt to keep Charlie’s presence on the series even after he left.

Only Jon Cryer’s performance gave any redeeming value to the Walden years, but he should have known to quit when Charlie left, as he alone cannot carry the show, as funny and neurotic as he is. Ashton Kutcher has acting skills, but he was miscast. And the truth is that there is no one who could fill Sheen’s shoes, and the show should have ended after season eight. Like Black Sabbath without Ozzy Osbourne, and like Van Halen without David Lee Roth, Two and a Half Men without Charlie Sheen just lacked the magic touch.